Sunday 16 September 2018
At first I was annoyed by GMail's "Smart Reply" buttons because they represent a temptation to delegate (more) shaping of my human interactions to Google's AI ... a temptation that, for some reason known only to Google, can be disabled in the GMail mobile app but not the desktop Web client. I do not want the words I use to communicate, or the words others use to communicate to me, to be shaped by the suggestions of an algorithm that is most likely opaque even to its masters, let alone a mere consumer like me.
I just realized, though, that they're potentially a lot worse than that. I got an email suggesting I take an action, and the suggested "smart replies" are:
- Sounds like a good idea.
- I like that idea.
- Yes, I agree.
For now I'm switching back to GMail Classic, and when (I assume) Google forces the new UI on me anyway, the path of least resistance will be to use a Firefox extension to block the Smart Reply buttons (yay Web!). Of course hundreds of millions of people will unwittingly submit to Google's reckless mental meddling.